Task Forces
Charging Futures Task Forces help identify options for a broad charging topic and support Ofgem in assessing these options. Each Task Force is made up of volunteers who actively contribute by identifying options, producing impact assessments, and engaging with wider industry participants.
Following Ofgem’s update on their thoughts around what is in and out of scope of the Task Force at the end of May 2022, the application process for becoming a member of the Transmission Network Use of System (TNUoS) Task Force was opened to industry.
The task force will look at:
- Root causes of the unpredictability of TNUoS charges and how these might be addressed.
- Examination of the input data into the current model used to calculate the locational element of TNUoS to ensure charges remain cost reflective. This will consider the inherent trade-off between improving predictability and cost reflectivity.
- NESO will be leading and providing coordination and administrative (secretariat) support for the task force. The scope for the task force and timetable for delivery of the outputs can be found in the terms of reference.
Task Force members
The Task Force members have been selected to bring together a group of people with a range of strengths and expertise and ensure balanced representation across different interests and roles within the industry.
Membership is made up of a range of TNUoS-interested participants, detailed below.
Role | Name |
Generator Task Force members | Stephen McKellar |
Grace March | |
Joe Dunn | |
John Tindal | |
Joseph Dunn | |
Lauren Jauss | |
Paul Jones | |
Adam Morrison | |
Storage operators Task Force member | Simon Lord |
Supplier Task Force members | Aled Moses |
Binoy Dharsi | |
George Moran | |
Sam Davies | |
Non-domestic energy users Task Force member | TBC |
Consumer representatives Task Force member | Sam Hughes |
National Grid Electricity Systems Operator Task Force member | Christian Parsons |
Ofgem Task Force member | Harriet Harmon |
Transmission Owner Task Force observer | TBC |
Distribution Network Operator Task Force observer | Kyle Smith |
Meeting resources
Meeting 1: 13 July, London | Agenda | Slides | Summary | Chair's post-meeting 1 thoughts |
Meeting 2: 10 August, virtual | Agenda | Slides | Summary | Grace March's pre-meeting 2 thoughts Chair's post-meeting 2 thoughts |
Meeting 3: 7 September, Solihull | Agenda | Slides | Summary | Joe Dunn's pre-meeting 3 catch-up |
Meeting 4: 5 October, virtual | Agenda | Slides | Summary | |
Meeting 5: 26 April, virtual | Agenda | Slides | Summary | |
Meeting 5.5: 17 May, virtual | Agenda | Slides | Summary | |
Meeting 6: 26 June, Warwick | Agenda | Slides | Summary | |
Meeting 7: 27 July, Warwick | Agenda | Slides | Summary | |
Meeting 7.5: 18 August, virtual | Agenda | Slides | Summary | |
Meeting 8: 15 September, Solihull | Agenda | Slides | Summary | |
Meeting 9: 11 October, Solihull | Agenda | Slides | Summary | |
Meeting 9.5: 25 October, virtual | Agenda | Slides | Summary | |
Meeting 10: 15 November, London | Agenda | Slides | Headline report | |
Meeting 11: 10 January, virtual | Agenda | Slides | Headline report | |
Meeting 12: 25 January, Solihull | Agenda | Slides | Headline report | |
Meeting 13: 27 February, virtual | Agenda | Slides | Headline report | |
Meeting 14: 27 March, London | Agenda | Slides | Headline report | |
Meeting 16: 30 May, Warwick | Slides | CUSC Mod Proposal | Headline report |
This Task Force has now concluded.
What was the scope of the Task Force?
The terms of reference outlined the scopes of the Task Forces, as well as what the expected outputs were. Their contribution and outputs were shared for review at the quarterly Charging Futures forums. They were also shared with the Charging Delivery Body, to consider the best route for implementation.
Task Force members
These Task Forces were chaired by Ofgem, supported by Energy Networks Association as secretariat. Task Force members were volunteers representing a spectrum of industry participants - from network users, network owners, and subject matter experts.
View the Task Force member list
Task Force publications
Final report and conclusions
In response to Ofgem's working paper on the "reform of electricity network access and forward looking charges," the Charging Futures access and forward looking task forces produced a report which outlines conclusions to support the reform.
If you would like to hear an introduction to the report, you can listen to our final task force podcast on iTunes or SoundCloud.
Initial progress report
Other documents
Ofgem published a working paper on reform of network access and forward-looking charges.
Meeting resources
15 May 18 - Joint task force meeting
Minutes |
17 April 18 - Joint task force meeting
Minutes |
21 March 18 - Forward-looking task force meeting
Minutes |
20 March 18 - Access task force meeting
Minutes |
20 February 18 - Joint task force meeting
Slides | Minutes | Actions |
25 January 18 - Forward-looking task force meeting
Minutes |
24 January 18 - Access task force meeting
Minutes |
21 December 17 - Forward-looking task force meeting
Agenda | Slides | Minutes |
18 December 17 - Access task force meeting
Agenda | Slides | Minutes |
1 December 17 - Joint task force meeting
Slides | Actions | Summary |
This Task Force has now concluded.
Ofgem asked the Electricity System Operator (ESO) to launch a Balancing Services Charges Task Force under the Charging Futures arrangements, to provide analysis to support decisions on the future direction of Balancing Services Use of System charges (BSUoS).
The ESO lead and provided coordination and administrative (secretariat) support for the Task Force. The scope for the Task Force and timetable for delivery of the outputs can be found in the terms of reference.
Task force members
The task force members are detailed below:
Name | Organisation | Role | |
Colm Murphy | National Grid ESO | [email protected] | Chair |
Joseph Henry | National Grid ESO | [email protected] | Technical Secretary |
Mike Oxenham | National Grid ESO | [email protected] | Member |
John Tindall | SSE PLC | [email protected] | Member |
Paul Jones | Uniper UK Ltd | [email protected] | Member |
Paul Mott | EDF Energy | [email protected] | Member |
George Moran | Centrica | [email protected] | Member |
Grace Smith | UK Power Reserve | [email protected] | Member |
Laurence Barrett | E.On | [email protected] | Member |
David Bird | Octopus Investments | [email protected] | Member |
Dr Graham Pannell | RES | [email protected] | Member |
Lisa Waters | Waters Wye Associates | [email protected] | Member |
Caroline Bragg | The Association for Decentralised Energy | [email protected] | Member |
Nicholas Gall | Solar Trade Association | [email protected] | Member |
Joseph Underwood | Energy UK | [email protected] | Member |
James Kerr | Citizens Advice | [email protected] | Member |
Rob Hudson | Tata Chemicals Europe | [email protected] | Member |
Tom Edwards | Cornwall Insight | [email protected] | Member |
Nigel Bessant | SSEN DNO | [email protected] | Member |
Tim Aldridge | Ofgem | [email protected] | Member |
Final report
The final report is now published, including an executive summary.
Read the draft report consultation responses
Our webinar from 7 May 2019 gave an overview of the draft report and draft conclusions. Please note that the analysis and conclusion shared in the draft report remain unchanged.
Meeting resources
29 January
Agenda | Presentation | Minutes | Podcast |
11 February
Agenda | Presentation | Minutes |
28 February
Agenda | Presentation | Minutes |
7 March
Watch the webinar | Read the slides |
12 March
Agenda | Presentation | Minutes |
26 March
Agenda | Presentation | Minutes | Podcast |
8 April
Agenda | Presentation |
24 April
Agenda | Presentation | Podcast |
7 May
Watch the webinar | Read the slides |
23 May
Agenda | Presentation |
This Task Force has now concluded.
As you may be aware, Ofgem published their final decision and impact assessment on the Targeted Charging Review in November 2019. Ofgem made an important announcement on the work of the Balancing Services Task Force.
The first Task Force concluded that Balancing Services charges should be treated as cost-recovery charges. In order to develop this work further, Ofgem requested a second Balancing Services task force, led by National Grid ESO.
The Task Force looked at applying the TCR principles to balancing services charges as a cost-recovery charge to consider how they should be recovered. The second task force looked at two specific questions:
- Who should be liable for Balancing Services charges.
- How should these charges be recovered.
The ESO lead and provided coordination and administrative (secretariat) support for the task force. The scope for the Task Force and timetable for delivery of the outputs can be found in the terms of reference.
Ofgem published their final view on the findings of the second Balancing Services charges Task force, which concluded in September 2020.
Ofgem are supportive in principle of the recommendations put forwards by the Task Force, which are as follows.
Who should pay BSUoS?
- BSUoS should be levied on final demand.
How should BSUoS be recovered?
- BSUoS should be a volumetric (£/MWh) charge.
- BSUoS charges should be fixed ex-ante.
- The combined length of fix and notice period should be 14/15 months.
What are the next steps?
Ofgem has indicated that solutions to deliver the Task Force’s recommendations will be developed through the code modification process. To support their evaluation of these proposals, Ofgem will undertake further work to:
- Explore the cashflow exposure to the ESO of managing a fixed BSUoS charge and any alternatives for which a different party manages the risk
- Undertake quantitative analysis to assess the net benefits of the proposals and the potential impact on energy intensive users
Read Ofgem's letter on its views on the findings of the Task Force.
Task force members
The task force members are detailed below:
Name | Organisation | Role | |
Colm Murphy | National Grid ESO | Chair | |
Joseph Henry | National Grid ESO | Technical Secretary | |
Jon Wisdom | National Grid ESO | Task force member | |
Andrew Rimmer | Engie | Task force member | |
Lisa Waters | Waters Wye | Task force member | |
Olaf Islei | Shell Energy | Task force member | |
Tom Steward | Good Energy | Task force member | |
Joshua Logan | Drax Group | Task force member | |
John Tindal | SSE Plc | Task force member | |
George Moran | Centrica | Task force member | |
Simon Cowdroy | RES | Task force member | |
George Douthwaite | RWE Npower | Task force member | |
Caroline Bragg | ADE | Task force member | |
Keith Munday | Bryte Energy | Task force member | |
Paul Jones | Uniper | Task force member | |
Joseph Underwood | Energy UK | Task force member | |
Tom Edwards | Cornwall Insight | Task force member | |
Grace March | Sembcorp | Task force member |
Final report
The final report of the second Balancing Services charges task force has now been published and sent Ofgem for consideration of the task force’s recommendations.
Meeting resources
30 January 2020
Agenda | Slides | Summary | Podcast |
12 February 2020
Agenda | Slides | Headline report | Summary |
25 February 2020
Agenda | Slides | Headline report | Summary | Podcast |
11 March 2020
Agenda | Slides | Headline report | Summary |
1 April 2020
Agenda | Slides | Headline report | Podcast |
8 July 2020
Agenda | Slides | Action log | Headline report |
20 July 2020
Webinar | Slides |
11 August 2020
Webinar | Slides |
2 September 2020
Agenda | Slides | Headline report |
9 September 2020
Agenda | Slides | Headline report |
17 September 2020
Agenda | Slides |
This group has now concluded.
The industry led access working group considered incremental improvements to the allocation of access rights, including better management of connection queues, allowing distributed generation with non-firm connections to trade with others to reduce the extent they are curtailed, and better enabling the exchange of access rights between users.
This group was made up of the network companies and the Electricity System Operator as established by Ofgem.
Get in touch
If you have any questions about any of the Charging Futures task forces, please don't hesitate to ask us at [email protected]
You can also join our mailing list to be informed of any new task forces.